Pin It

The Silent Treatment 

click to enlarge An image from _Into Great Silence_ by Phillip Groning
  • An image from _Into Great Silence_ by Phillip Groning

Every documentary maker can relay a torturous story of how many years it took them to pursue their cinematic dream. Between the first plans to film a subject and the day the film screens, there lies a tale of heartbreaking setbacks and intermittent triumphs. But when German filmmaker Philip Gröning inevitably mounts the podium to collect his Oscar next year for Into Great Silence, his story will best them all.
Anointed by BAFTA (the British Academy Awards) in 1984 as a young Munich-based director on the rise, Gröning embarked that year upon an audacious project: a documentary about the secretive monks of the Carthusian order of the French Alps. A letter seeking entry to their secret world was answered tersely: It was not the right time. So Gröning went about his career, making features and winning awards. In 2000 the monks summoned Gröning. Now, they told him, it was time.
Founded in 1084 by Saint Bruno of Cologne, this order settled in an alpine monastery near Grenoble, France. In addition to an intense devotion to religious studies, they are also farmers, craftsmen, and, most famously, distillers of a potent verdant herbal brew known to connoisseurs as Chartreuse. Their plain, hooded garb suggests a cult of medieval Jedi knights.
Gröning ultimately spent six months living among the monks of La Grande Chartreuse, serving as sole filmmaker and soundman for his documentary. Even those monks who opposed the project eventually helped him carry equipment. Those seeking an exposé—Carthusians: Beneath the Hood?—will find unanswered prayers in this digital scrapbook. Gröning makes no effort to dig beneath the surface of monastic life nor religious commitment.
There is no narration to the film. The monks, who spend each week in silence and are allowed conversation only on Sundays, do not speak to the camera. Gröning does not interview them. (However, several do agree to sit for the camera and stare placidly into the lens. The effect is both fascinating and unnerving.) When these wards of heaven do chat amongst themselves, they passionately debate scriptures.
In its narrative austerity, Into Great Silence still offers myriad rewards. In every scene, the director wields his camera like a modern-day Vermeer, obtaining stilllifes of startling depth and muted color. We watch the change of seasons from mountaintops, observe melting icicles. We see monks emerge from their simple cloisters to pray with an intensity incomprehensible to our ADHD society. All moments are recorded by utilizing natural light and sounds. When the brothers unexpectedly “kick back” on a wintry Sunday afternoon, their laughter is like a splash of ice water on our lulled senses.
Painstakingly, Gröning has conjured the Carthusian existence. Biblical epigrams about servitude to God and renunciation of earthly goods flash recurringly on the screen to complete the effect. Whether you find the filmic experience hauntingly transcendent or—at 162 minutes—incredibly mind-numbing depends on your own capacity for simple joys.

Into Great Silence will be screened at Upstate Films in Rhinebeck beginning June 8. (845) 876-2515;

Speaking of...


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Readers also liked…

  • Parting Shot: Susan Copich

    Susan Copich's photographs pack a wry punch. She casts herself front and center throughout her "Domestic Bliss" photo series, alongside her daughters and husband, mocking and engaging viewers in scenes fraught with dark humor.
    • Aug 1, 2015
  • Field and Dream: Collaborative Concepts at Saunders Farm

    Over 70 artists from the Hudson Valley and beyond have assembled animal-friendly sculptures to complement the surrounding landscapes—grazing cows and horses are imagined to admire the pieces while they dine.
    • Sep 1, 2015

Hudson Valley Events

submit event

The Hudson Valley from Pen to Brush

Mondays-Fridays. Continues through May 19 — Exhibit by Judith Beringer Hraniotis....
Interlock: Color & Contrast in Abstraction @ Carrie Haddad Gallery

Interlock: Color & Contrast in Abstraction

March 22-April 30 — An exhibit that explores the tensions of color and contrast in minimal...

View all of today's events

Latest in Visual Art

  • On The Cover: Gabriel Garcia Roman
  • On The Cover: Gabriel Garcia Roman

    "Visceral Notions" will feature work by Gabriel Garcia Roman through March 26 at the Center for Photography at Woodstock.
    • Mar 1, 2017
  • Andres Serrano Goes Back to School
  • Andres Serrano Goes Back to School

    The Andres Serrano retrospective at The School, the spectacular exhibition space established by Chelsea gallery owner Jack Shainman in Kinderhook, is a rare event.
    • Mar 1, 2017
  • Parting Shot: Matthew Pleva
  • Parting Shot: Matthew Pleva

    Kingston-based multimedia artist Matthew Pleva seeks inspiration from everything around him.
    • Mar 1, 2017
  • More »

Related to Visual Art

More by Jay Blotcher

Hudson Valley Tweets