Book Review: And She Was | Books & Authors | Hudson Valley | Hudson Valley; Chronogram
Pin It

Book Review: And She Was 

click to enlarge And She Was, Alison Gaylin, Harper, 2012, $7.99
  • And She Was, Alison Gaylin, Harper, 2012, $7.99

Richard Bach has said that there is no such thing as a problem without a gift for you in its hands. The warmhearted and indefatigable private detective created by Alison Gaylin in And She Was is living proof. Impacted hugely by her own sister's disappearance when she was a child of 10, Brenna developed a rare psychological condition called hyperthymestic syndrome, in which every experience is imprinted on the conscious mind in minute detail and vivid, intrusive memories can well up so suddenly and intensely that the past threatens to overwhelm the present. 

For a detective, it is both a handicap and an asset. Brenna has had to develop coping skills to refocus her attention in the here and now, and has found ways of putting her renegade memory to work for her. She sublimates the anguish of not knowing what happened to her older sister into locating missing persons, at which she excels. She's got a 27-year-old pretty-boy assistant whose attitude toward women drives her to distraction, a sometimes-tense relationship with her teenage daughter, and an Internet friendship with her journalist ex-husband.

The unsolved case of a vanished child, Iris Neff, has haunted her for years. Now a new case is pulling her back to Tarry Ridge, the town where Iris disappeared, and there's a tenuous but intriguing connection between the missing woman and the child she failed to find. It's this connection and her commitment to justice that keep Brenna on the case when the missing woman turns up dead in the trunk of her client's car and the police decide it's a simple domestic homicide.

Brenna has her doubts, and manages to find one ally on the police department; when other people with connections to the matter die at an alarming rate, she is even more convinced that nothing about the case is simple. The scarier things get, the deeper she delves and the more determined she becomes, powering her way through blind alleys, anguish, and danger.

Something smells bad in Tarry Ridge, and as Brenna follows the scent, it becomes obvious that the fish is rotting from the head down: Her adversaries are powerful and connected. A handful of clues—an altered case file, a mysterious blue car, strange phone calls and a child's drawing—are enough to keep her in pursuit even after her client fires her and apparently hangs himself, leaving behind a written confession.

Anyone might give up, but Brenna has instinct and nerve to spare. The pieces will fit together, and she will find out how. The villain she's up against, the psychopathic tool of the outwardly respectable forces controlling Tarry Ridge for their own benefit, is a deeply scary dude. Fortunately, her assistant has a brain in that pretty-boy head (and top-notch computer skills), and her cop buddy an honest heart.

Gaylin breathes life into her characters and crafts an engrossing and moving mystery that twists and turns, building to a terrifying climax; your heart will be racing along with the plot for the last few chapters. She paints a savvy picture of corruption and its consequences, and a woman wrestling with her issues and pinning them to the mat. Readers of And She Was can rejoice: A sequel is coming in the fall.

Readings: 3/3 at 6pm at Woodstock's Oriole9, sponsored by Golden Notebook. 3/17 at 2pm at Kingston's Barnes & Noble.

Pin It


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Hudson Valley Events

submit event
Dan Devine: Impact @ Thompson Giroux Gallery

Dan Devine: Impact

Mondays, Thursdays-Sundays. Continues through May 5 — A solo exhibition....

View all of today's events

Chronogram on Instagram

Latest in Arts & Culture

  • Five Fantastic Hudson Valley Events for Your Calendar
  • Five Fantastic Hudson Valley Events for Your Calendar

    From world-class live music to a woodworker’s dream sale and Hudson’s hippest reading series, it’s all here, waiting for you.
    • Apr 17, 2019
  • AMR Spring Art Show at the Commons Building
  • AMR Spring Art Show at the Commons Building

    The Spring Show hosted by the AMR Artists, which opens on April 19 at Upstairs at the Commons gallery in Margaretville and remains on view through May 13, will include works by 20 participants working in different disciplines: painting, monotypes, photography, tapestry, installation, and even jewelry.
    • Apr 11, 2019
  • Turkuaz & Brass Against Play BSP Kingston on April 19
  • Turkuaz & Brass Against Play BSP Kingston on April 19

    Radio Woodstock and BSP Kingston have teamed up to bring something very funky to Uptown Kingston this Spring. On Friday, April 19, the nine-piece power-funk ensemble Turkuaz takes their rainbow-themed, dance-heavy show to BSP Kingston’s historic back room theater.
    • Apr 10, 2019
  • More »