CD Review: So Tough | Music | Hudson Valley | Hudson Valley; Chronogram
Pin It

CD Review: So Tough 

click to enlarge David Greenberger and a Strong Dog, So Tough, 2013, Pel Pel Recordings
  • David Greenberger and a Strong Dog, So Tough, 2013, Pel Pel Recordings

Since 1979, painter, musician, recurrent NPR commentator, and erstwhile nursing home activities director David Greenberger has used his conversations with the elderly to create evocative art. His 'zine, The Duplex Planet, served as his first canvas, soon morphing into various media, including recordings. So Tough is the 17th CD on which he recites lyrics woven from ongoing interactions with folks in decline. The versatile trio A Strong Dog accompanies him this time out, offering up Tom Waits-y soundscapes, back-porch blues stomps, delicate Ry Cooder-isms, and swaggering rock, all dovetailing behind Greenberger's recitations of oldsters' observations and memories.

Rather than imitate, Greenberger abstracts lines from chats, delivering them plainspoken and gently inflected. When combined with the effortlessly simpatico music, these pieces become oddly powerful, often hilarious. One recalls how, for millennia, old folks were integral to everyday life, and whimsical, sometimes softly harrowing snippets of speech were commonplace. But Greenberger's no nostalgia hound; his work focuses on how these people are now. And he's not making a statement about a youth-obsessed culture, either, which is refreshing. With So Tough, the operative word, in fact, is often acceptance. In the slide guitar-drenched "Landlords, Maids, and Men" and the Peter Gunn-ish "Once in a Whirlybird," subjects look back on rough times without anger, while the atmospheric "Tramp in the Woods" and the minor-to-major saxophone romp "Halloween's Over" present snapshots of rich, living memory as intimate shares, the building blocks of new friendships with old people.

Speaking of...

Pin It


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Readers also liked…

Hudson Valley Events

submit event
Bengali Bandhan @ Hudson Area Library

Bengali Bandhan

Fridays, 4-5 p.m. Continues through April 20 — These classes, taught by MD Gazi and Kaniz Fatema, are open to...

View all of today's events

Latest in Music

Related to Music

  • The Moonlights Sunday Brunch
  • The Moonlights Sunday Brunch

    The Moonlights, a debut musical collaboration for families, is making the rounds at a series of live performances, including two of the upcoming Sunday Brunch at the Falcon in Marlboro.
    • Mar 20, 2017
  • Opera in Phoenicia Park
  • Opera in Phoenicia Park

    With its open-air format, where attendees picnic in the parks and watch the stars emerge during performances, and its $5 youth tickets, the Phoenicia International Festival of the Voice is the perfect place to share with children a love of music and theater, in a variety of styles.
    • Jul 25, 2016
  • More »

More by Robert Burke Warren

Readers' Favorites

Chronogram on Instagram