Esteemed Reader | September 2019 | Esteemed Reader | Hudson Valley | Chronogram Magazine
Pin It

Esteemed Reader | September 2019 

In order to create, it is necessary to be liberated by voluntary death, the death of the ego. Creative vision only belongs to one who dares to look into the depths of himself as far as the void. —Jeanne De Salzmann, The Reality of Being

She never stumbles, she's got no place to fall She's nobody's child, the Law can't touch her at all —Bob Dylan, "She Belongs To Me"

Esteemed Reader of Our Magazine:

When my two boys were small we had the garden-variety battles of will. Something needed to happen—going to school or to a gathering, raking leaves, practicing an instrument, or signing up for a class or activity. Every so often, as we struggled about whether this or that thing would happen, they would ask the key question.

"Do I have a choice?"

My answer was always the same.

"Of course you have a choice. It is one choice—the thing that must be done."

This was not the answer they expected or wanted. As they did the math, they found that it didn't add up. How could only one option represent choice?

"That's not fair, Dad! It makes no sense" they argued.

"It makes perfect sense," I countered. "You can choose the inevitable. Instead of the task being foisted and your participation coerced, you can bring your will to it and make it your own. Then it is truly your choice."

Though they denied that they understood my meaning, I know that they did, because I saw them secretly struggling with themselves to first of all accept and then choose the inexorable eventuality.

"Delivery from preferences, from your likes and dislikes," I lectured, as their eyes began to glaze, "is real freedom of choice. Only when you are free from the desires for one or the other can you have the perception and discernment to see what liberates creative possibility."

Now the boys are teenagers, and we laugh about those early lectures. Recently, one asked if my nuanced argument was a subtle form of coercion. I said it was true that it was easier for me if he had cooperated, and that my true aim was to give him a chance to see that his resistance could be transformed into a positive intention.

Laying it out for children is far easier than dealing with similar dilemmas in myself. I am faced with this collision of yes and no many times a day. Sometimes it has a sharp quality, like the shock of the queue ball hitting its mark on a pool table. Other times it is a slow burn, a simmering resentment that another person is behaving other than how I want, something isn't happening as it should, or that I am unable to rise to an occasion and accomplish the work that is needed.

In these events I am confronted with the feeling that there is no escape from an insoluble conflict and contradiction. Like being crucified, I see no way out and can easily collapse into anger, hopelessness, or some variant of dissociative withdrawal.

In the midst of the struggle, I recognize my helplessness in the face of the dilemma and perhaps catch a fleeting glimpse of the nothingness at the core of all the sturm und drang. Of a sudden it looks like that scene from Vanilla Sky in which Tom Cruise walks through an empty and silent Times Square.

Struck by an unexpected silence, I become aware that an invisible source of help is present, an energy which is at the same time an intelligence. Movement becomes possible in the situation that was, only moments before, utterly intractable. The help is silent, like an angelic hand reaching down from the Cloud of Unknowing.

When I see that I can do nothing and that I am reliant on a source of help beyond my own resources, I see that real choice is no choice at all. What is needed is to choose what leads to refinement, to something new. Allowed to be completely honest, I see that the real choice, the only choice is always clear.

The words of Krishna to Arjuna on the battlefield in the Bhagavad Gita echo through all time: "Great hero! Cut the knot of ignorance in your heart with the sword of self knowledge, and do your duty!"

Pin It


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Hudson Valley Events

submit event
Bliss Body Yoga with Linda @ Got2Lindy Carriage Barn Studio

Bliss Body Yoga with Linda

Tuesdays, 11 a.m.-12 p.m. Continues through April 11 — Feel better in your body. This therapeutic yoga class is designed for...
Boots on the Ground @

Boots on the Ground

Tue., Feb. 7, 6-7:30 p.m. — Veterans are invited to join us for an unmounted, hands on experience...

View all of today's events

Chronogram on Instagram

Latest in Lifestyle

It’s high time Chronogram made a newsletter about marijuana. Stay in the know with the latest on dispensary openings, industry news, cultivation tips, and more as we cover the emerging cannabis scene in New York and the Northeast. Welcome to High Society.


* indicates required