Letters to the Editor | General News & Politics | Hudson Valley | Hudson Valley; Chronogram
Pin It
Favorite

Letters to the Editor 

robot.jpg

The Feminine Vernacular

To the Editor:

On page 114, in the June 15, 2015, issue of Chronogram, a wonderful magazine I must say, I read a review of the sci-fi film Ex Machina.

I would first like to point out that the review (written by a man) was about a film that was written and directed by a man; and secondly that the film was about a man who is seduced by a female robot; a female robot that has been programmed with the male employee's sexual preferences. Sexual predilections acquired through nefarious means of privacy intrusion when the employee was on the Internet.

Is this every guy's dream? Or every geek's dream? To have a female programmed to his personal and specific likes and dislikes? I suspect that might be the case.

Does this film (or even this review) apply to females? Is the world around the reviewer, which the reviewer creates quite clearly, in his article "Life With and Within the Robot," a world seen primarily through male eyes? Yes it is. And therefore, it doesn't equate or transfer or translate equally into the female vernacular.

Think about that in reverse. A brainy, computer-talented, female employee is singled out by a genius-Geek female employer who is rich and powerful, who lives and works in a magnificent hideaway where, by spying and collecting data on what the female employee views (when said employee goes onto the Internet), the employer has created and programmed a handsome male robot out of the specific sexual likes and dislikes of the female employee. And then the male robot does its version of the Free Willy thing, leaving the female to die. How does that sit as a translation that would be acceptable by a major film studio, such as Disney?

I adore sci-fi! Lets be clear about that, I will take it any which way it comes, whether it's in a book, short story, magazine article, on tape, on film, or in a poem. But it's primarily male, from Hitchhiker's Guide to Star Wars and then over to Avatar, just like the New York Times crossword puzzle is primarily male. And therefore, the script of Ex Machina, like every other covert version of the Barbie-versus-Roger Ramjet fairytale, falls into an expected role scenario where your reviewer, and the film itself, promotes a set of strictly segregated mores which continually put men and women into culturalized straitjackets where they will ultimately fail. And even when we get the powerful acting of bilingual Sigourney Weaver in Alien, what do we get? We get one female fighting another female. As terrific a film as it was, the only thing that was missing from that subjugating fantasy was the mud.

For a change, wouldn't it be great to have a woman review a male-based sci-fi thriller? And vice versa, a male writer review a female-based sci-fi thriller? Or maybe reviews written by a female writer and a male writer set side by side. Now, that could be exciting and informative.

Aria Creek, Beacon

Lost Possibilities

To the Editor:

The May issue made me think of what was left unsaid. The fascinating profiles of Alejandro Jodorowsky and Leon Botstein brought home the point that each of these creative, sensitive people descend from ancestors that fled the Cossacks and the Nazis. Each of them lost relatives in the pogroms and the Holocaust, and the world is a lesser place for what those lost relatives might have contributed to society. Perhaps another Botstein would have made a medical breakthrough, or another Jodorowsky might have penned a profound novel. We'll never know.

For many Jews, such as myself, we can only lament the lost possibilities. The current issues in Israel/Palestine have become the new prism from which the Gentile community perceives Judaism. And that's a shame. (I am neutral on that issue, having deep sympathies for both sides.) I hope that one day, Jews will once again be seen in the global community as producers of avant-garde cinema, thought leaders on postsecondary liberal arts education, and many other issues. Thank you, Leon and Alejandro, for keeping the torch alive.

David Sterman, Gardiner

Darn Cats!

To the Editor,

I enjoyed your story "Little Red Bird" [Editor's Note, 5/15] so much. Thank you for writing it and for saving the Little Red Bird!

You are right about outside cats. They are hyperpredators, not only killing a staggering number of birds every year, but countless other defenseless creatures as well. The American Bird Conservancy—Abcbirds.org—sides with you (and me!) and has a website encouraging keeping cats indoors.

Again, thanks for writing such a good and timely story. I look forward to your next one and to your next issue of Chronogram!

Melinda Taylor, via e-mail

Star of the Stars

I sing monthly praise to the wise man you feature each and every month in the pages of Chronogram. Of whom do I speak? Chronogam's Eric Francis!

Myrna Hilton, Woodstock

Speaking of Letters, Ex Machina

  • Life With and Within the Robot
  • Life With and Within the Robot

    The Internet is an environment, and by a definition I like to work with—that of Marshall McLuhan—an environment is an invisible phenomenon. Most people do not consider the Internet a robot, but that's exactly what it is, and it's exactly how we use it.
    • Jun 1, 2015
  • The Souls of Typewriters
  • The Souls of Typewriters

    Alon is with his typewriter and looking for collaborators the first Tuesday of every month at Quinn's in Beacon starting at 7pm. He will also be at Beacon Pantry in Beacon on May 16-17 for Beacon Open Studios, and at the Clearwater Festival at Croton Point Park on June 20-21.
    • May 1, 2015
  • Editor's Note: January 2011
  • Editor's Note: January 2011

    Brian K. Mahoney writes about upcoming events, letters to the Editor, and "Lord of Misrule."
    • Dec 30, 2010
  • More »
Pin It
Favorite

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Readers also liked…

Hudson Valley Events

submit event

Read and Feed

Sun., July 23, 12-5 p.m. — Basilica Hudson's festival of literature and food returns for a second year,...

Reading/Booksigning with Judith Boggess: Confessions of a Bar Brat: Growing Up in Rosendale, New York

Sun., July 23, 1-2 p.m. — Judith Boggess's memoir of growing up in Rosendale as the child of...

View all of today's events

Latest in General News & Politics

  • Larry Beinhart's Body Politic: Is There a There There?
  • Larry Beinhart's Body Politic: Is There a There There?

    Why do all the people around Trump get agitated whenever the word "Russia" pops up? Commentators are baffled. What's there to hide? They ask: "Is there any there there?" In real journalism, you can't deduce what's inside the black box of the White House. An insider has to speak or a paper must be leaked. Yet in physics, chemistry, and biology it's quite normal not to have testimony from inside. Scientists look at what's going in and what comes out, then make up a story about what's happening unseen. If it sounds good, it's treated as the truth until some new facts are observed that don't fit.
    • Jul 2, 2017
  • While You Were Sleeping for July 2017
  • While You Were Sleeping for July 2017

    Diana Waldron compiles odd news headlines from June 2017.
    • Jul 2, 2017
  • While You Were Sleeping for June 2017
  • While You Were Sleeping for June 2017

    The gist of what you may have missed for June 2017.
    • Jun 1, 2017
  • More »

More by Chronogram Staff

Hudson Valley Tweets