Pubs, Clubs, and Grub: New Paltz by Night | Community Pages | Hudson Valley | Chronogram Magazine
Pin It

Pubs, Clubs, and Grub: New Paltz by Night 

Last Updated: 11/06/2019 10:35 am
click to enlarge Main Street at dusk. - PHOTO: ROY GUMPEL
  • Photo: Roy Gumpel
  • Main Street at dusk.

You might know New Paltz for its college campus. Maybe you've driven down Main Street on your way to the Mohonk Mountain House or the trails of Minnewaska State Park and the Mohonk Preserve. New Paltz is a rural town with the frenetic energy of a small city; it's home to students and transients and artists and academics. During the day, the streets are chaotic. Traffic builds up from the New York State Thruway; students rush to and from class, professionals drive back and forth to work.

click to enlarge The outdoor patio at Huckleberry. - PHOTO: ROY GUMPEL
  • Photo: Roy Gumpel
  • The outdoor patio at Huckleberry.

At dusk, this momentum comes to a lull, but don't be fooled: New Paltz isn't going to sleep. You catch your breath and watch the sun set, over the mountains, the sky peppered with streaks of gold and violet, before settling into the dark. It's nighttime. Restaurants and watering holes are open late, the town is still churning, but more relaxed. Main Street branches off into quaint side streets that turn into rail trails and footpaths. The town evokes a quiet, nocturnal magic. You can start off the evening eating vegan mac and cheese at Commissary and end up drinking beer at Snug Harbor, an anchor to a hard night out. SUNY New Paltz students gravitate towards bars with patio seating, huddled around a chiminea, drinking and chatting comfortably, like it's their own backyard. Nights in New Paltz offer a glimpse into its singular culture through adventures you'll relive with hazy nostalgia, convinced you were given the keys to a secret society or a private party. Through candid photographs of bar crawls and garden parties, this series is a portal to the town's afterhours ambience. Welcome to New Paltz at night.

click to enlarge B-Side Grill. - PHOTO: ROY GUMPEL
  • Photo: Roy Gumpel
  • B-Side Grill.

Nightlife is integral to New Paltz's artistic identity. It beckons transplants from New York City and neighboring municipalities, creators looking to manifest their vision in a place that simultaneously inspires it. Communal hubs like B-Side Grill, Bacchus, and the multifaceted Water Street Market embody the town's spirit of innovation, offering a salon-like atmosphere for people to converge, turning any given into a rural, bohemian version of WeWork. Those who find their creative apex at night will find inspiration in wonky, drunken antics set to a backdrop of beatific stars.

click to enlarge The patio at The Parish at Water Street Market. - PHOTO: ROY GUMPEL
  • Photo: Roy Gumpel
  • The patio at The Parish at Water Street Market.

Every generation has its own version of New Paltz nightlife. The few remaining bars from the 1970s attract erstwhile residents and new patrons alike. They fuse with their contemporary neighbors, places like Huckleberry (a Brooklyn-esque gastropub) and the retro burger joint B-Side Grill. The iconic building at the corner of Main and North Chestnut used to be home to Neko Sushi and before that, McGuinn's pub. Now it's home Lola's Café, an affable spot serving funky boutique wines.

click to enlarge P&G’s Restaurant & Bar. - PHOTO: ROY GUMPEL
  • Photo: Roy Gumpel
  • P&G’s Restaurant & Bar.

Clubs may close, but the music goes on. Oasis and its subterranean lounge, Cabaloosa, were mainstays of youth culture in New Paltz for a decade, hosting Battle of the Bands competitions, comedy shows, and jazz. Both closed in 2018. Anywhere else, they'd leave a dearth of live entertainment. Instead, indie music devotees conjured new venues, inspired by memories of nights spent jamming at Oasis. There are open-mic nights in Peace Park. Crossroads, a community organization cofounded by two SUNY New Paltz seniors, now hosts house parties.

click to enlarge The billiard hall at Bacchus. - PHOTO: ROY GUMPEL
  • Photo: Roy Gumpel
  • The billiard hall at Bacchus.

New Paltz is deceptively small: The plethora of bistros and bars may induce sensory overload for the unsuspecting visitor orbiting the town's worldly cuisine, where you can find everything from Thai, farm-to-table, sushi, Indian, authentic Italian and Mediterranean fare, grass-fed burgers, and burritos. There are sports bars, Irish pubs, hip wine bars, late night coffee shops, and dive bars. Dive in. Follow your instincts: You'll end up somewhere that suits your taste, and imbibe with strangers who, by the end of the night, become close friends.

click to enlarge Denizen Theater. - PHOTO: ROY GUMPEL
  • Photo: Roy Gumpel
  • Denizen Theater.

The duality of New Paltz allows raucous partiers and subdued introverts to coexist. Music echoes from bars and clubs every night of the week, sirens luring you to dance and drink until last call. Step outside for a more low-key vibe, relax, look at the stars, and watch the world go by while you nurse a craft beer.

click to enlarge Les Jones and Simeon Tuttle at Inquiring Minds Bookstore. - PHOTO: ROY GUMPEL
  • Photo: Roy Gumpel
  • Les Jones and Simeon Tuttle at Inquiring Minds Bookstore.

It's a walkable town, like a hip Manhattan neighborhood—imagine Greenwich Village or Hell's Kitchen, with more trees. SUNY students roam the streets at night with an unquenchable thirst for adventure, for the next party. Their youthful vigor propels New Paltz, their energy pulsating throughout the community. Restaurants and bars are open late to satisfy student whims, but everybody benefits from a town that never sleeps. These people and places alchemize the spirit of New Paltz. You will inevitably find what you didn't know you were looking for. One night in New Paltz is enough to make you feel like you've lived here forever. It welcomes you to add color to its mixed-media collage, a town constantly on the precipice of change, with a vast recollection of what came before.

click to enlarge Jessie Stanko bartending at Jar’d. - PHOTO: ROY GUMPEL
  • Photo: Roy Gumpel
  • Jessie Stanko bartending at Jar’d.

Because of New Paltz's indisputable legacy, new establishments can emerge, and serve trends on a cocktail tray without a hint of inauthenticity. Jar'd Wine Pub and Fuchsia Tiki Bar indulge in the cultural zeitgeist of 2019, catering to those who crave novelty along with aperitive spirits. Jar'd opened in 2013, just before wine bars became a national obsession. Its cozy location in the Water Street Market means you can't bring 10 friends along to sip organic, sparkling rosé, making the experience even more appealing. It's exclusive in this sense yet eschews the highbrow sommelier attitude that may turn young people off from wine culture. Jar'd even serves kombucha, which is as New Paltz as it gets.

click to enlarge From left: Jenny Hayward, Caitlin Nagel, and Maggie Wynn at Fuchsia Tiki Bar in New Paltz. - PHOTO: ROY GUMPEL
  • Photo: Roy Gumpel
  • From left: Jenny Hayward, Caitlin Nagel, and Maggie Wynn at Fuchsia Tiki Bar in New Paltz.

Fuchsia Tiki Bar takes a note from 1930s cocktail culture, another reemerging nightlife trend. It's a tropical paradise in the heart of New Paltz, giving patrons the sense that they've entered a portal to another dimension. Decorated with palmetto-print wallpaper and hot pink countertops, the bar gives patrons a genuine feel for the Polynesian bars of yesteryear. Fuchsia's owners worked for months to craft recipes using fresh ingredients, deviating from the overly saccharine flavors found in cocktails from chain restaurants like P.F. Changs. Is it a coincidence that tiki bars, first popular during the Great Depression, are back in vogue during the Trump administration? Who's to say, but you can visit Fuchsia Tiki Bar for a taste of escapism, which is always in style when the world feels haywire.

Pin It


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Hudson Valley Events

submit event
Cool & Collected '23 @ Kenise Barnes Fine Art

Cool & Collected '23

Thursdays-Sundays, 11 a.m.-5:30 p.m. Continues through March 5 — Kenise Barnes Fine Art is pleased to present the 2023 iteration of...
"Through the Eye of the Needle" @ Hudson Valley MOCA

"Through the Eye of the Needle"

Jan. 21-March 18 — Group exhibition of handcrafting featuring Inez Andrucyk, Jan Baracz, Jill Bell, Anita...

View all of today's events

Chronogram on Instagram

Latest in HV Towns

It’s high time Chronogram made a newsletter about marijuana. Stay in the know with the latest on dispensary openings, industry news, cultivation tips, and more as we cover the emerging cannabis scene in New York and the Northeast. Welcome to High Society.


* indicates required