A protester chants amid a sea of signs at Kingston’s No Kings rally, where opposition to ICE enforcement and authoritarian policies drove thousands into the streets. Credit: Dean Goldberg

“Not to speak is to speak,” Dietrich Bonhoeffer, the German anti-Nazi dissident wrote, and on Saturday in Kingston, a few thousand people decided they had said enough by saying nothing.

They showed up at Academy Green with signs—so many signs—each one a small act of refusal, a cardboard brief against the present tense of American politics. If you wanted to take the temperature of the moment, you didn’t need a poll. You just had to read.

“Dear Congress, F**king do something.”
“Trumpty Dumpty.”
“Dirty Don the chaos king divides the people to reign supreme.”
“I’m proud and thankful for my immigrant grandparents. ICE out.”
“The ruling class is why we can’t have nice things. No billionaires. No oligarchs. And definitely no kings.”

Some were angry, some funny, some handmade with the careful block lettering of someone who had spent a long time getting it just right. One featured a pink toad in a crown—grotesque, surreal, unmistakable. Another diagrammed parasites—ticks, worms—before landing on a familiar quartet of billionaires. A teenager held a sign that read, “Teens shouldn’t have to protest the actions of adults. Even I know right from wrong.” Nearby, someone else had opted for brevity: “Unpaid and agitated.”

The march moved out from the Green and into the streets, a long, steady river of people. An accordion player kept time. Someone banged a drum. A man in a black cap that read “Vote bitches” stood wrapped in an American flag like a counter-argument. Another marcher carried a sign that read, simply, “Gimme an F!”—the rest left to the crowd to supply.

Photo: Brian K. Mahoney

It was local, unmistakably so—Kingston being Kingston—but it was also part of something much larger. Across the country, millions turned out in more than 3,000 No Kings rallies, the latest in a series of mobilizations that have grown in size and intensity since last summer. The issues animating them have only multiplied: the war with Iran, aggressive ICE operations—including incidents that have left U.S. citizens dead—the continued erosion of asylum protections, and a foreign policy that has veered from saber-rattling to outright adventurism.

What’s notable is not just the scale, but the spread. These aren’t just big-city protests. They’re happening in places like Kingston, Delhi, Monticello, and Warwick—towns that don’t usually see themselves as epicenters of national politics but are increasingly behaving like they are.

And the mood has shifted. There’s still humor—there always is—but less whimsy than before, more clarity. The signs feel less like satire and more like statements. Less clever, more direct. The crowd, too, feels different: not just activists, but people who look like they have crossed some internal threshold, from watching to participating.

Photo: Dean Goldberg

That shift matters, especially with a midterm election on the horizon. Protests don’t vote, but they do indicate where energy is building—and energy, if it sustains, tends to find its way into turnout.

It’s too early to say whether No Kings will translate into electoral change. American politics has a way of metabolizing dissent without altering course. But standing on the sidewalk as the march passed—hundreds upon hundreds of people, signs bobbing, voices carrying—you could feel something coalescing. Not just opposition, but cohesion.

A movement that knows what it’s against, and is starting to understand what it might be for. The signs said it plainly enough. No kings. No oligarchs. No patience left for either. And in Kingston, at least for an afternoon, that wasn’t just a slogan. It was a crowd.

Brian is the editorial director for the Chronogram Media family of publications. He lives in Kingston with his partner Lee Anne and the rapscallion mutt Clancy.

Join the Conversation

8 Comments

  1. What a joke. Most of us are rolling our eyes. The fringe think its a “movement” but their idealized views contradicts reality.

    1. Most of us rolling our eyes, Fred? We are half the country. Is it the War, pedophilia or the obscene private moneymaking that you like best?

  2. You couldn’t be more wrong Fred… Unless by “Us” you mean Maga. I am a conservative republican who regrettably voted for this buffoon on the first go round. Enough is enough. I get it that 20 years of Democrats bending over to appease every fringe group out there is at the root of this current situation. It made me vote for a mid course correction in his first term. I quickly grew to regret my mistake.
    The thing I regret to see is that the protestors are using the same language that your self appointed King has made the new normal. I’m far from a prude but it is not OK to use F Bombs to get your point across. If we can’t keep our decorum for our children then we are slipping into the same abyss as Maga. Shame on those that do regardless of what side they are on.
    A king builds a grand ballroom gilded in gold. He names buildings after himself. He gets his signature on currency and of course a gold coin. He makes his own rules and disregards centuries of laws and Supreme court rulings. Every day I shake my head in disbelief that this is accepted by anyone with any decency or sense of fair play.

  3. Fred, Fred,
    Thanks for the high, outside pitch.
    Climb out of the Fox News salad,
    Before we’re all
    Dead in a ditch.
    And John,
    I sympathize.
    Yet many feel the need
    To scratch their itch.
    Voices long contained,
    Explode.

  4. Say it soft enough, it turns to truth,
    Repeat it loud, rewrite the proof,
    Dress it up in careful speech—
    And suddenly it’s what we teach.

    Call it care, erase the line,
    Redefine what’s by design,
    If words can bend, then facts can too—
    Just shift the lens, adjust the view.

    Say gender flows, unbound, unnamed,
    Old definitions now seem shamed,
    What once was clear is now unmade—
    A moving target, ever swayed.

    No border crossed, just seekers here,
    Change the label, kill the fear,
    If laws feel harsh, just change the word—
    And conscience quiets, undisturbed.

    Cry “dictator” loud and fast,
    Make the warning always last,
    If every foe’s a tyrant king—
    Then none mean quite the same thing.

    It’s not a lie if all agree,
    It’s just a new reality,
    Where truth’s not found, but built and sold—
    And doubt is something we’re not told.

    So say it soft, or scream it clear—
    The goal’s the same: reshape what’s real here,
    Not what is—but what should be,
    A world remade by decree.

    And maybe more than who is right,
    Or who has won the louder fight,
    The deeper loss we face today—
    Is truth we’ve let just drift away.

      1. Biological Realities: Democratic party denis that there are only two biological sexes, rejecting scientific consensus on sex differentiation in favor of gender identity ideology.
        Border Security and Immigration Law: Democrats deny the necessity of a secure border, or the negative impacts of illegal immigration, such as the influx of criminals and drugs.
        The Impact of Crime Policies: Democrats deny the negative consequences of “restorative justice” policies and bail reform, which some say make schools and cities less safe and empower criminals over victims.
        Economic Impact of Regulations: Democrats deny that high taxes and heavy government regulations stifle economic prosperity, hinder job creation, and hurt small businesses.
        The Merits of Energy Independence: Democrats deny the necessity of fossil fuels in the current economy and that their push for renewable mandates harms American energy independence.
        Historical Origins of the Party: Democrats deny or obscure the fact that their party was originally the one that supported slavery, fought against civil rights legislation, and only switched to a strategy of creating dependency on government for votes.
        The Failures of COVID-19 Lockdowns: Democrats refuse to acknowledge the long-term harm to children’s education, mental health, and the economy caused by strict school and business shutdowns.
        The Need for Electoral Integrity: Democrats deny that certain election security measures, such as voter ID laws, are necessary, frequently labeling them as voter suppression.
        The Reality of Inflation Causes: Democrats deny that high government spending, particularly under the Biden-Harris administration, was a primary driver of high inflation, attributing it instead only to outside factors.
        The Legitimacy of Opposing Views: Democrats refuse to acknowledge the validity of conservative viewpoints, often labeling them as “racist” or “extreme,” rather than engaging in debate.

        Your ignorance must be blissful.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *