For six hours at Citi Field on November 15, Elana Carlson worked behind a six-foot table with a toaster, a griddle, and two bagel sandwiches to keep coming. One was whitefish salad, the other chicken Caesar. There were pumpernickel, cinnamon raisin, and rosemary salt bagels, plus fermented jalapeno and corn schmear and garlic basil schmear. Three people worked that table. “You just put your head down and don’t look up,” Carlson says of the frenzied carb load that is New York BagelFest. Out front, head baker Abi Gallant and assistant baker Ryan talked to judges and festivalgoers. Back in Kingston, the shop sold out.
Fantzye Bagels came home from the November 15 New York BagelFest with four silvers. The festival’s blind-tasting judges awarded one for Best Sourdough. Attendees voted Fantzye second in People’s Choice, Best Beyond the Boroughs, and Rising Star. In all three crowd-voted categories, the lineup was identical. Rise Bagels of Irvine, California, took gold, Fantzye took silver, and Hey Bagel of Seattle took bronze. Hey also won Best Sourdough, a result Carlson took with the good humor of an extremely competitive person who’d have preferred to win. “I find it hard to believe that we’re not the best sourdough bagel,” she says. “But that’s OK.”
Carlson had reason to expect gold. In 2024, when Fantzye was still a pop-up and the Midtown Kingston shop hadn’t opened, festivalgoers voted it Best Beyond the Boroughs and runner-up for Rising Star. In 2025, Fantzye won Best Sourdough and Schmear of the Year for its charred leek and lemon caper entry. It also took second for Best Bagel overall, behind Dallas’s Starship Bagel, and third for Best Beyond the Boroughs.

That first festival gave Carlson some assurance that the bagels she’d been making on Martha’s Vineyard and in borrowed upstate kitchens would draw a crowd when she opened a shop of her own. Two years into the Hasbrouck Avenue storefront, which marks its anniversary November 27, the festival serves more as a chance to see how a year’s worth of tinkering lands with people. Someone even placed a preorder to pick up at Citi Field. Carlson says customers sometimes bring the bagels back to the city themselves, including frozen ones from Big Rock Market in Stanfordville.
The Fantzye bagel takes four days. The bakers build the starter, prepare an overnight preferment, mix the final dough, and give it two days in the cold. The goal is tang and chew under a blistered crust, the kind of bagel that can make its case plain in a blind tasting and still hold up to a chicken Caesar. When we spoke last year, Carlson described how Gallant and the team track the variables in spreadsheets and still rely on how the dough feels to decide when it’s ready. Pumpernickel was still in development then. This year it was among the bagels Carlson says people were excited to see at the table.

Carlson says Fantzye now has the base of regulars it was still building in year one. The shop is profitable, she says, and paying down its opening debt. She still handles the general manager’s job herself. The price of a bagel with cream cheese has held at $6 since opening, though the shop nudged up the price of loose bagels after looking at how much labor goes into each one. For anyone who’s seen a weekend line and kept driving, Carlson points out that online orders can be picked up by the coffee station.
Next year may bring the return of the food trailer parked around the corner. Carlson got the generator running again, and the trailer already has a griddle, refrigerators, and a fryer. It once turned out hundreds of bagel sandwiches at the farmers’ market on Martha’s Vineyard. It could be doing the same around the Hudson Valley come spring.
There’s already talk of trying bialys or an olive bagel. Carlson is also thinking about specials people ask her to bring back, like the Little Morty. And then there’s BagelFest West in Los Angeles next April. “They can come here and take our medals,” Carlson says of West Coast bagel slingers. “Why can’t we go out there and take there’s?”









