The first time Candice Guardino brought the man she would marry home to meet her family, he wanted to turn around before they made it through the front door. It was a Sunday, the windows were open, and he could hear what he took to be a fight. Guardino assured him this was a conversation. He suggested they come back another time. “Even if you’re two feet away or 20 feet away, we’re yelling,” she says.
On December 6, Guardino brings that family to the Bardavon in Poughkeepsie in “Italian Bred,” her solo show about growing up Italian American on Staten Island. She plays her mother, her father, her grandmother, and assorted relatives and neighbors, a cast she began assembling long before she knew there was a show in it. “I was a shy kid, so I was more of the observer,” she says. Her family has since learned to be careful around her. The running joke, she says, is “Don’t say it in front of Candice, it’s going to end up in the show.”
“Italian Bred” grew out of an impression of her mother in a comedy set. Once Guardino started switching between relatives, she could see the audience following along “as if there were 10 people up there with me.” She figured the 15 minutes could be 90. Early on, theaters would hand her a microphone, and she’d ask for a headset. “I said I need my hands.” Her father, who grew up in an auto body shop, talks with two fingers pointed like a pistol. Her mother goes up into a high register when she gets nervous, a family trait for which Guardino’s training as a soprano has proved unexpectedly practical.
At her grandmother’s apartment on Ocean Parkway in Brooklyn, there was always music playing. Frankie Valli and Connie Francis kept her grandmother company while she cooked, and somehow, she could seat 25 people in a small kitchen with a mix of folding tables, snack tables, and whatever chairs were available. When Guardino wrote scenes about her, she could hear the records in her head. Onstage, that becomes a rendition of Francis’s “Where the Boys Are.” Another story takes her back to a college audition, where, lacking a prepared Shakespeare monologue, she recited from Rocky and sang “On My Own” from “Les Miserables.”
One story that got a woman to stand up laughing involves a christening and an envelope. The family had taken money back out of the envelope because the food was lousy. “We do that,” the woman told Guardino.

There’s a filmed version of “Italian Bred” on Prime Video, but the touring show keeps changing as Guardino and her relatives get older. Marriage, motherhood, and aging parents have given her more to write about. She works in new songs, including parodies and originals, and near the end of the show hands the storytelling over to the audience. At one performance, a woman told a story about her wedding in the ’80s and asked Guardino if she knew the wedding song, “Unchained Melody.” She did. They sang it together.
Another audience member wanted to know why Italians always eat in the garage. He’d seen photos online, he explained, with the garage doors up and folding tables inside. Guardino’s family still gets 35 people together for Easter, and she had a straightforward answer. “We do that because we’ve now outgrown the kitchen,” she told him. Her grandmother, who could get 25 people around the tables in that Brooklyn apartment, might have held out a little longer.
Candice Guardino performs “Italian Bred’ on December 6 at 3pm the Bardavon in Poughkeepsie. Tickets are $41.50-$61.50.









